Take the High Ground and Hold It
I am a student of history. Consequently I am addicted to the news. Lately I've been watching a debate take place that I never would have dreamed take place. It involves the debate about whether torture is justified in the war on terror. To me the answer is assinine and the fact that the debate is taking place seems to be something out of an Orwellian nightmare.
What is America? When is it destroyed? When does it go from being the "last greatest hope of humanity" to a mere post script in the history books? Is it when our land is laid waste by some nuclear terror? Is it when, heaven forbid, we replace our president with a dictator? Is it when our land is occupied or owned by other nations? Or is it when we change who we are? What would it take to extinguish the light of our blessed republic.
To find that answer I would cite four documents: The Declaration of Independence, the American Creed, the American Constitution and the Pledge of Allegiance.
The Declaration of Independence states that "ALL men are entitled to the pursuit of life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness." At the time that was written a war was being waged on our soil. Our homes and farms were being burned, our citizens terrorized, and our soldiers were often times treated as traitors. Yet during all this what did we say? Did we state that WE were entitled to those rights? If you missed my point, please reread that quote again. It does state ALL men, including those who were burning the homes and yes, "terrorizing" our citizens were entitled to them. We recognized that people had a right to be treated like humans evens when others didn't. How is torture equivalent with that, the document upon which our very nation and way of life is founded?
Our own constitution states, "We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity...". I will grant you that torture will ensure domestic tranquility because one is far more reticent to commit a crime if they know that torture is part of the punishment. It will probably even ensure our common defence because nations fear other nations that practice torture (ie Nazi Germany). But how does it contribute to our general welfare? Cheney states that this practice has stopped conspiracies that would have saved countless American lives. Of course he can't give the specifics of those conspiracies because it would compromise national securities. Perhaps the specifics would but couldn't he give us at least one broad example? Are we so vulnerable that merely discussing threats compromises our security?
The Constitution also states that we are to ensure our liberty for our posterity. I'll point out two things. First children learn by example so what lessons are they learning merely by the very debate of this issue much less the practice? Do we really want them to have this stain upon their generation as we have let this practice stain ours? Second, may I remind people that Arabs have extremely long memories. There are times, when speaking with Arabs, that I have found them bringing up the crusades, which happened one thousand years ago. Now if they remember things from a millenia ago do you really think that they will forget things from the 21rst century? They're still fighting about the first round of insults that we gave them a thousand years ago so who knows how long they will remember the most recent? How is insulting someone know to hold a grudge helping posterity?
The Pledge of Allegiance, states that we believe in "liberty and justice for all." The American Creed describes us as a "democracy in a republic, a sovereign Nation of many sovereign States; a perfect union, one and inseparable; established upon those principles of freedom, equality, justice, and humanity for which American patriots sacrificed their lives and fortunes." Where does torture come into the picture.
The fact is Mr. Cheney, America is much more than a nation. It is a dream, a shining example, and in the words of the great Abraham Lincoln "the last greatest hope of humanity." The values extend beyond our borders to humanity as a whole. We are to set the example for the world, and the fact that we have, up until recently, been seen as the greatest nation in history. That's what makes us great.
I grew up in the Cold War Era and there was a saying that was very prevalent- "Better dead than Red". What did that mean? To mean the answer is obvious. It would be better to die for who we are then to change and live as someone we're not. I can't speak for anyone else, but if I am to be a victim of another 9-11 style terrorist attack, I would consider it an honor to lay down my life for a country that defended such noble principles. The fact is Mr. Cheney you may very well have saved the lives of our citizens, but only time will tell what you have done to our country.
Mr. Obama, you have chosen to take the high ground. I, for one, can assure you that I am completely behind you in this endeavor regardless of the cost. You and I know what it means to truly be American and I for one am willing to live as nothing less.